In Focus: Financing Reform

Sep 3, 2010  |  PERMALINK »

It's Time to Realign Child Welfare Financing Structure to Support the Outcomes We Want for Children and Families

by Rutledge Q. Hutson

On July 29th the U.S. House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Income Security and Family Support held a hearing on how child welfare waiver demonstration projects can be used to promote child well-being. Rutledge Q. Hutson testified at that hearing arguing that reauthorizing child welfare waiver authority is insufficient to alter the outcomes for children and families in the child welfare system. Instead, Ms. Hutson argued that we need comprehensive financing reform - reform that will both infuse new resources into and redirect resources within the child welfare system to provide needed services and supports that keep children out of foster care whenever safely possible. At the conclusion of the hearing, Chairman McDermott and Ranking Member Linder expressed interest in what comprehensive financing reform would entail and requested all witnesses to provide supplemental testimony outlining their ideas for such reform. The following are excerpts from Ms. Hutson's supplemental testimony.

The vast majority of federal support for child welfare is available only after harm has occurred and children are removed from their families. The single largest federal child welfare source of funding generally cannot be used to prevent child abuse and neglect from occurring nor to intervene when it is still possible to keep a child safely at home.

While Fostering Connections took many critical steps towards improving outcomes for children who enter foster care, it did relatively little to try to prevent children from needing to enter foster care in the first place. There was broad recognition that the more difficult challenge of realigning the financing structures to prevent abuse and neglect and avoid foster care when possible remained.

CLASP believes there are three broad components of comprehensive financing reform:

  • Expanding Title IV-E funds to support the full continuum of services needed by children who have experienced or are at risk of experiencing child abuse and neglect.
  • Increasing support to enhance the child welfare workforce.
  • Increasing accountability - both fiscal accountability and accountability for the outcomes children and families experience.


Jul 29, 2010  |  PERMALINK »

Children and Families Need More than Child Welfare Waivers \xe2\x80" Comprehensive Financing Reform is Necessary

Below are excerpts from Rutledge Q. Hutson 's July 29 testimony before the U.S. House Ways and Means Subcomittee on Income Security and Family Support. The subcomittee hearing focused on the use of child welfare waiver demonstration projects to promote child well-being.

The current child welfare system lacks the capacity to address the needs of children who are abused or neglected, and the vast majority of federal resources to address these needs are available only after a child is removed from his or her home.

For the last decade, between 750,000 to 1 million children have been found to be abused or neglected each year. Data also indicate that nearly 40 percent of the children for whom allegations of abuse or neglect are substantiated get no additional services.

Most of the staff I've known over the years, from the directors and commissioners to the front line workers, have been dedicated and caring and given their all to help children and families.  Yet, it is as if they are fighting with one hand tied behind their backs.  The financing structures that currently exist simply do not provide states, localities or workers with the tools they need to address the challenges children and families face.

In the current economic environment, even the most creative of child welfare leaders cannot find the funds to piece together supports that will keep children safely in their homes.  They are facing budget cuts to a range of services that help low-income families-services that can be used to help keep children safely with their families

To turn around the outcomes for children and families, to ensure that fewer children are abused or neglected, and to ensure those who are abused or neglected receive the supports and services they need to heal, the nation must give state and local child welfare agencies the tools needed to do the job.   




Feb 4, 2010  |  PERMALINK »

President's Budget Calls for Key Investments in our Most Vulnerable Children and Families

By: Rutledge Q. Hutson

Our nation's children will be safe and well cared for only when we invest in a continuum of services including: prevention and early intervention services that help prevent child abuse and neglect whenever possible; effective treatment services for children who experience maltreatment and their families; and aftercare services that support children and their families once a crisis is stabilized so that further abuse and neglect do not occur. President Obama's 2011 budget takes a number of positive steps towards supporting this continuum, but The Administration and the Congress must take additional steps to make up for years of underinvestment in critical services for our nation's most vulnerable children.

Prevention and Early Intervention Investments in the Budget:

The reasons for child maltreatment are varied and often complex. For example, some families neglect their children because they lack adequate resources to meet their basic needs while other families mistreat their children under the stress of losing a job or home. For these families, many of the provisions in the budget designed to create jobs and provide economic supports to families will help prevent maltreatment. For example, the President's proposal reverses a decade of indifference in child care and Head Start programs proposing an increase of more than $2.5 billion. Similarly, the Administration's proposal to continue the TANF Emergency Fund created under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act will help ease the stress of the current economic situation for many families.

Substance abuse, untreated mental health issues and domestic violence are also related to child maltreatment. The President's budget calls for an increase of $11 million for the Family Violence Prevention Fund. The Administration proposes to level fund the basic substance abuse block grant and the mental health block grant, but proposes to increase funding for children's mental health services by $5 million and to increase funding for substance abuse Programs of Regional and National Significance by $55 million and to increase mental health Programs of Regional and National Significance by $13 million.

Budget Investments for Child Welfare Focused Programs:

The Administration proposes to increase Child Abuse and Treatment Act (CAPTA) funding by $10 million by creating a new competitive state grant program for evidence-based prevention practices, for a total budget line of $107. The President requests level funding of $360 million for child welfare services, (subpart 1 of Title IV-B of the Social Security Act). The budget also calls for level funding of Promoting Safe and Stable Families (PSSF) (subpart 2 of Title IV-B of the Social Security Act). This request includes $63 million in discretionary funding, $360 million in mandatory funding and an additional $20 million in mandatory funding to reauthorize the Court Improvement Program which expires this year. The Administration's budget also includes mandatory funds for foster care, kinship guardianship and adoption through Title IV-E of the Social Security Act at just over $7.2 billion. The Administration includes a proposal to continue the increased match rate for Title IV-E (enacted as part of the Recovery Act) for 6 months, but still anticipates that funding for the program will decrease due in part to more children moving out of foster care into permanent homes and in part due to increasingly fewer children being eligible for federal payments because eligibility is linked to 1996 income criteria for the no longer existing Aid to Families with Dependent Children program.

Budget Investments in Comprehensive, Holistic Approaches to Families and Communities:

The budget also includes two exciting proposals that could lead to investments in more comprehensive approaches to helping children and families who have long struggled and who have been hit hardest by the current economic crisis. First, the Administration proposes a $210 million investment in its Promise Neighborhoods initiative which seeks to strengthen distressed communities by linking school reforms, strong family supports and effective community services across neighborhoods. This approach recognizes that parents do not raise their children in a vacuum but are influenced by the communities in which they live and acknowledges that raising children is much easier when they live in neighborhoods with child care providers and schools that promote healthy development and provide quality education, with multiple pathways to family-sustaining jobs, and with enriching community spaces and places (parks, libraries, grocery stores etc.)

Second, the Administration proposes the creation of a $500 million Fatherhood, Marriage and Families Innovation Fund which will provide three year competitive grants to states. These grants can be used to help families who struggle with the most complex challenges to employment - challenges which also often interfere with parenting - and will be available to states who are ready to innovate and offer holistic approaches which provide a range of services such as home visiting, subsidized employment and transitional jobs, substance abuse and mental health treatment. 

site by Trilogy Interactive